Antikythera Mechanism (Part II)

Ctesibius was fortunately to be born in Alexandria, a place where all the knowledge of the ancient classical world was held in one vast library, a place where the great thinkers of antiquity studied, and where shelves held the thousand of scrolls recording their work. The library was such a great institution, that people came here from all over the world to learn and to invent. It was here that Ctesibius’ revolutionary invention was recorded, and where the young Archimedes may first have read his work. Ctesibius is a figure who is often forgotten in history, yet his work paid off the way for technical revolution—the measurement of time.

Yet Ctesibius came from humble beginnings. He was a son of a simple barber. As a young man, he worked at his father’s shop at Alexandria, inventing gauges such as adjustable mirrors. And here he was surrounded by the constant dripping of water, which would inspire his great invention. Ctesibius knew for thousands of years the Egyptian used ordinary water timers to mark the hours of day. The famous Karnak water clock is one example. Despite the intrigued hieroglyphics, strange symbols and images of gods and animals, it’s a simple device, as the reproduction shows. It was filled to the top of water and as it ran out through a spot at the bottom, the time could be read as the level dropped. Markings inside show the passing hours, but these varied as the number of hours from sun rise to sun set varies from month to month. The clock allowed the ancient Egyptians to measure the passing of time during the day or night, but this is still only a timer, not a constant clock.

In sophisticated ancient Greek society, the ability to tell the time accurately had become extremely important. Their society needed order and schedules which meant they had to be able to tell the time accurately. Sundials could be used at certain times and could be seen on important surviving universal buildings such as the Tower of the Winds in Athens. But when the Sun went behind the cloud, or night fell, how would they know what time it was then? The first Greek solution to this age-old dilemma was their own water timer, called Clepsydra, or “water thief”.

Tower of the Wind, by Georg Zumstrull

“The Clepsydra was an elegant device for measuring periods of time. In most examples it gave an equal amount of time to lawyers in a court room, or speakers at a particular assembly. It worked very simply. You filled the large vessel with water, and when you were ready to start timing, you simply took the bump out of the bottom, and the water ran slowly out of the vessel.” said Christopher Kelly.

Lawyers and minor legal cases may have been allowed the time it takes one clepsydra to empty to give their argument. However for a serious case like a murder a whole row may have been needed to allow more time for evidence. But when the water was gone, your time was up. It was the origin of the phrase “running out of time” but that was quite literally what happened. For breaks or over night a bump could be put in effectively pausing the session.

“The clepsydra has one significant limitation,” said Christopher Kelly, “it’s a timer, not a clock. The problem is when the vessel is full, the water gushes out of the bottom. But as the water level drops, so the pressure reduces, finally to a dribble.”

Klepsydra - Water Clock: Reconstruction of a clay original of the late 5th cent. B.C. Ancient Agora Museum in Athens.

The ancient Greeks made their clepsydra more and more ornate but they still had the same problem—the fact the water ran more quickly at the beginning than the end. They created graduated scales to compensate for this but they couldn’t make it run at a constant speed. Ctesibius, however, solved the solution. He realized that if the vessel was always full, then the water pressure would always be the same. If he could master that, he knew he could create an accurate device which would change the world. This thing was the challenge he decided to settle himself.

“Ctesibius thought that the way to simplify the Egyptian clepsydra was not to utilize outflow of water,” said Dr. Alan Mills, University of Leicester, “but to try and obtain uniform inflow of water.”

Dr. Alan Mills, a researcher of University of Leicester, has used classical references to Ctesibius’ work to build a replica of one of his earliest water clocks.

“It’s very sophisticated. It’s one of these inventions that is easy once some geniuses had thought of it.” Alan Mills added.

The challenge was to keep the reservoir of the clepsydra full at all times. As this is how Ctesibius did it, firstly he added another water tank about the main reservoir. This pulled water into the top faster than it could flow out, meaning the reservoir was always full. And any excess water could just run off into an overflow container. The water would always come out from the reservoir at the same speed. Now Ctesibius just had to measure it. To do this, he decided to put another water tank under the constant outflow. In this container, he placed a float with a pointer on top and the scale next to it. When the level of the water rose, the pointer rose at a constant speed. It was a stroke of a genius! Ctesibius had created the world’s first mechanical clock, thanks to the dripping water in a barber shop.

He had harnessed the power of water and in the process he had become a master of time. But measuring hours and minutes was only the start. What else could this unique water clock do?

The answer to that was kept here in the great library of Alexandria. Anyone in the ancient world wanted to understand time could come here and read Ctesibius’ books, which described the wonderful machines he was now building and the whole new subject he invented – hydraulics. Before long his clocks were not just dripping taps, but ornate machines decorated with gilded figures of gods and animals. And their workings were yet more elaborate too. He devised the complex scale for the hours too, showing here in white for the day and blue for the night. One nymph holding a shell from which drips the constant supply of water, whilst another travels up the scale holding the pointer that indicates the hour of the day or night. But that was only the start. He even used water to sound the whistle and make a model owl move. He had invented the world’s first cuckoo clock. Increasingly complicated series of gears of wheels also allowed the scale to rotate very slowly to indicate the days within each month of the year. This clock now is also a calendar, and automatic, day and night, month and year, cuckoo clock.

Archimedes was clearly fascinated by Ctesibius’ creations. He started his clocks, and used own genius for inventions to continue the work. In an Arabic translation of Archimedes’ work, dating back over a thousand years, we can see a tantalizing glimpse of his editions to Ctesibius’ water clocks. This modern reconstruction shows Archimedes’ elaborations to Ctesibius’ clock. He had a bird who drops small stones onto a bell, making the clock chime on the hour. The woman is a Gorgon, with snakes for hair. When the bell triumphs, you look up to see her eyes change color indicating the time. This is the first automatic chiming clock in history. One could only imagine the spectacle when Archimedes unveiled his daring design. In Greek mythology, anyone who looked into the eyes of the Gorgon would be turned to stone. But with Ctesibius’ help, Archimedes could the man who dared to look into the face of the Gorgon.

Alexandria today is a busy modern port. A new building now stands in place of the famous library. Tragically, the original library was burnt to the ground and with it was lost nearly all the knowledge of the ancient world. Only a very few ancient texts remained which mentioned Ctesibius’ work. We may never know what else he invented as none single page of his own work had survived.

So much information has been lost, that Ctesibius has been largely forgotten. However, there is one legacy of his work, one clue, which is still standing. This unassuming tower topped away to a corner of Athens is one of the best preserved buildings from antiquity. Its survival almost untouched is a miracle and one due to fact for centuries it was believed to be the tomb of the philosophers Socrates and Plato. But it isn’t a tomb. Carved on the eight faces a clue to its weird use, on each side a sculpture of eight winds can still be seen, along with a sundial. It was actually built by an astronomer around two hundred years after the death of Ctesibius, but it’s a monument to his genius. The building, now known as the Tower of the Winds, was the public clock of ancient Athens. Inside this tower, there once stood a huge and complex water clock, based on Ctesibius’ design.

This clock was fed by a constant stream of water which ran from a spring on the acropolis, from which the whole population of Athens could tell the time. But this was more than just a clock or a calendar. Some believed this strange building had the device and even charted the movement of the Sun and Moon in relation to the constellations or zodiacs. We know the Greeks were measuring hours, days and months during the time of Ctesibius. Could it be that they also had also started to look up above and measure the heavens? One man believed the answer may lie in the wheels of the Antikythera mechanism.

In 1951, an English physicist, Derek de Solla Price, decided to find out for himself and examined the mechanism in detail for the first time. De Solla Price traveled to Athens to look at the mechanism. The pieces had lain largely untouched since its discovery fifty years earlier. The device had disintegrated further exposing pieces of the gears which was able to study. He began determined to crack the secret of the Antikythera mechanism.

Derek de Solla Price

De Solla Price spent much of his time at the National Museum of Athens probing the secrets of the ancient enigma. Something told him that these fragments were the real treasure from the Antikythera wreck.

Using new development of X-ray technology he could now see what the discoverers fifty years before could not. Looking through the corrosion, he was amazed. A machine, so complex, it could almost be modern. He had to know what it was for. His meticulous studies of the cogs, gears and inscriptions gave him clues to the possible purpose of the mechanism.

Remnant of a wooden box which held the device also had the Greek writing on, which gave further tantalizing hints. Using this information, de Solla Price developed a theory and put together a model of how he believed the Antikythera mechanism could have worked. He realized the mechanism was an extremely sophisticated device for calculating the relative movement of the Sun and Moon. It also seemed to show the days of the month as lunar phases. De Solla Price has established its mechanical complexity and knew that the knowledge acquired to create such a machine was immense. He believed in the front of the mechanism the bronze dial showed the date and the positions of Sun and Moon. A dial at the back would indicate the month, possible within the twelve months in a year. A further dial at the back seemed to show either a cycle of 47 months or four years. De Solla Price called the mechanism a “calendar computer”. For anyone in the ancient world, such a device would be invaluable. To understand the movement of the Sun and Moon within the heavens was to look into the minds of the gods. Many believed then, and some due today, that the positions of the Sun and Moon and stars of the time of someone’s birth may influence their later life. What complex horoscope software does today the Antikythera mechanism may have done over two millennia earlier. To the priests and astrologers of the day, this extraordinary machine could have been a window on the gods.

But where could such a device come from? De Solla Price had an extraordinary theory. What if machines like the Antikythera mechanism would be part of the municipal clock powered by the very water clock that Ctesibius invented? What if it were in a common place in the Hellenistic world? Was this is a secret to the Tower of the Winds, not just a sundial or even a clock, but an automatic model of the Sun and Moon within the universe? De Solla Price so suggested that building these machines was what interested the great Archimedes. Perhaps the Antikythera mechanism was a later copy of one of Archimedes’ machines? De Solla Price published his findings in 1974 in an article entitled “Gears from the Greeks”. The article generated a storm of international interest.

In particular, one man was to read that article and to spend the next thirty years pondering on de Solla Price’s theory. When Michael Wright from the Science Museum, first grabbed the paper, he was immediately fascinated by the notion that the ancient Greeks had complex engineering. Wright decided to go to Athens to examine and re-X-ray the mechanism for himself.

“We’ve got these few, with several pieces put together, and it helps me to build up a more complete picture of just how the gear wheels were arranged inside the box before they fell apart.” said Michael Wright.

Although intrigued by de Solla Price’s theory of the Antikythera mechanism, Wright believed there was more to the device than de Solla Price had realized.

“I went back and wrote “Gears from the Greeks” scaled, and started to find problems with Price’s account. That’s what I resolved I really had to look at the thing for myself.” added Wright.

But for Michael Wright to understand this strange device, he knew he needed to do more than just looked at it. He needed to build one for himself. After de Solla Price’s publication, many academics simply refused to admit that the mechanism could be so old. The complex gearing seemed too modern. How could ancient people solve calculating they precisely cut the fine teeth on each wheel, they asked? Surely this either was a fake, or a later machine just happened to be lost on the site of the ancient wreck. So Wright set to work, determined to prove them wrong.

Using only tools similar to those available in the ancient world, and with the Greeks’ knowledge of geometry, he set out to copy the elaborate gears in his workshop. Measuring and cutting gears with only apparent compresses, a metal file, and good eyes for detailed was not to be easy, but it was possible. After many hours of practice, Wright proved beyond doubt that with patience and skill, it could be done.

“You can’t deny the evidence of the Antikythera mechanism exists,” said Wright, “When you look at it closely, it’s a very accomplished work, both in design and execution. Why shouldn’t the ancient Greek have done it?”

We know from translation from his work that Archimedes was familiar with these types of cogs. And now it was the study of these gears that was to help to solve yet another mystery involving one of his mechanical marvels – the mystery of odometer. We all use odometers every time we get in a car. It’s the device which the distance we’ve traveled. But remarkably, this device was in use long long before cars, and it was crucial to the development of the Roman Empire.

Next I’ll further introduce the odometer devised by Archimedes. Stay tuned!

Antikythera Mechanism (Part II)

Antikythera Mechanism (Part I)

I attempted to record what I heard in one of the episodes of Ancient Discoveries series called the Antikythera mechanism as I’m wholly intrigued by this magic and incredible device that was invented over two thousand years ago.

Here goes the text.

Human civilization has come a long way over the last two and a half thousand years. This ancient classical world must have been a much different place to our modern age. A time when life is much simpler, a time without the stresses of modern life, in a world without computers and information technology, but we may soon have to change our biased view of the ancient world. Clues from the bottom of the Mediterranean Sea set the view this was a world more advanced than we could ever imagine.

In ancient discoveries, we will travel back to ancient times to discover the amazing ancient routs of technologies we’d like to think of as modern. New researches begin to suggest that many of the inventions of the last two hundred years may in fact have already been known to the ancient Greeks and Romans. Much of what we recently discovered, we may in fact just rediscover. “The Greeks and Romans are also intensely practical people. Many of the things which they devised, planned and invented preceded by two thousand years, think as we’d like to think of, as modern,” said Dr. Christopher Kelly, from University of Cambridge.

At the heart of the story of ancient achievement, lies a mysterious and arcane machine, one so complex that many have to refuse to believe it could be built by the ancient Greeks. Hidden for centuries beneath the Mediterranean Sea, encased in thick corrosion, it remained an enigma until twentieth century science glimpsed inside. What they saw inside astonished them—a massive gears and cogs, a machine. But what it was for? And who had created it?

For a hundred years, it has been a riddle which intrigued but baffled those who tried to understand the mysterious object, known as the Antikythera Mechanism. But now, finally, its story can be told.

That story began just over one hundred years ago in the year 1900. It was early spring when Captain Kondos and his crew of sponge divers found themselves sheltering from a storm miles off course by the little Greek island of Antikythera. As the weather cleared, the captain decided to make the most of his unplanned stop by diving in the deep clear water of the island. The water was deep, some 200 feet, but then the deep water was where the best sponges were found. But so far down, there was always the danger a diver might return to the surface with the notorious bends. Once in the water, the diver started his first decent. But what awaited him on the bottom were not sponges. As he looked around, he saw what appeared to be a dead body scattered in all directions. Terrified, he quickly signaled to be pulled back to the boat. Some thought the diver mad, perhaps he had the bends. But the truth was far far stranger than that.

Two thousand years ago, another ship assailed these waters, on its way from Rhodes, to deliver a precious cargo to a wealthy Roman citizen. Just like the sponge divers, the ship has also been caught in a storm. She too was driven far from her course, to the island Antikythera. But this ship was not destined to survive. Here she sank, and here she still lay. Captain Kondos sent another diver to investigate the wild story of dead bodies. What had at first appeared to be dead bodies were in fact the most beautiful marble and bronze statues imaginable, the remnant of that ancient wreck. Along with the statues, other treasures such as decorated Greek vases and jewelry were winched to the surface. It was the finest of the decade, perhaps the century, and the breathtaking statues made front page news. One of the most perfect bronzes recovered was named the Antikythera youth. The piece was universally acknowledged as a work of genius. It did clearly belong to a Roman of exquisite test and fantastic wealth, a Roman destined for disappointment, as this cargo never arrived. Along with the youth, a find known as the Philosopher’s Head were the highlights of the wreck. Two faces had not been seen the other world for over two thousand years. But the greatest work of the genius from the wrecks still lay unrecognized. This rusting lump of corrosion held the key to one of the greatest periods in human history, the Hellenistic period, and perhaps the greatest achievement of that time.

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

Two and a half thousand years ago the Mediterranean was the place where science, philosophy and art flourished. The Greeks, known as Hellenes, were living in what many regarded as Golden Age. They invented democracy, opened up the fields of mathematics and science, and introduced the world philosophy. They were inquisitive and inventive, no difference in many ways from us today. In trying to understand their world, they had created this strange machine. All the twenty-first century descendant had to do was to work out what they had created for. Part of the answer lay far from Antikythera, in a London museum display case.

Twenty years ago Michael Wright, curator of engineering at the Science Museum in London, came upon another mysterious ancient mechanical device. Although much less complex, there were similarities with the Antikythera Mechanism.

“We call this the Byzantine sundial calendar,” said the curator, “we think it dates from about 500 A.D.”

Byzantine Sundial Calendar, by M.T. Wright, London

It appears to be sundial, which is also a mechanical calendar. It shows the passing of the days, indicated by the age of the Moon within a month. The gear wheels look surprisingly modern. Complicated mathematics and detailed knowledge of astronomy would have been necessary to create such an object. Michael Wright decided to build a model of the device to explore how it would work. The model shows the position of the Sun and Moon within the Zodiac at any given date, as well as the age of the Moon.

Byzantine Sundial Calendar, model by M. T. Wright

When the letter appears to be letter Α, the device correspondingly shows a black disk for the Moon. As the wheel is turned day by day until the letter Ο appears, the disk turns to a fully shining one indicating the full Moon and so forth. The other two dials show the Moon and the Sun going around the Zodiac. “The instrument is much simpler than the Antikythera Mechanism,” said the curator, “but what is exciting about it is to find another instrument very obviously in Hellenistic tradition, because the Greek lettering, and also have gear wheels. So now we have not just one mechanism that tells us the Greeks had gears, we have two. We’ve doubled the evidence.”

Although similar, it is estimated that the sundial calendar only had 8 gear wheels, while the Antikythera Mechanism had at least 29, allowing for much more complicating calculations. Could the Antikythera Mechanism be a mechanical calendar as well? One many times more complicated than the Byzantine machine, yet over six hundred years older. But in an age supposedly without machines and modern technology, who could have created such a device? They would have to be expert both in mathematics and engineering, a genius, centuries, perhaps even millennia ahead of that time. One man who fitted that description, was Archimedes, the most respective mathematician and inventor of his age.

Archimedes lived during the Hellenistic period in a Greek city state Syracuse on what is today Sicily, off the coast of Italy. During his life time, the Mediterranean was a turbulent war-torn place, a world in which his talent for military invention was put to good use by both his follow Greeks, and the aggressive new power of Roma, that was slowly spreading its tentacles across the Mediterranean. Today, he is perhaps best remembered for the revolutionary invention known as the Archimedes screw, used to move water or seeds uphill. But Archimedes was also fascinated by other difficult mechanical problems, such as how to accurately measure distances. The greatest challenge of all, however, was to solve the puzzle of what cause the rising and setting of the Sun, the changing seasons, and the strange movement of the Moon and planets. What, in short, were the mechanics of time?

Many years earlier, Archimedes traveled across the Mediterranean to the most cultural centre of the Hellenistic world—Alexandria, Egypt. Alexandria was the most sophisticated place on Earth, founded by Alexander the Great. It was now ruled by the descendant of one of his generals, Greek soldiers, who were reasoned to become pharaohs. It was a unique place, the meeting point of the age-old civilizations of the Mediterranean, a city of Egyptians, Greeks, Romans, and Persians. Here they combined the wisdom of the Pharaohs with the brilliance of the Greek philosophy to create the intellectual power house of the ancient world. And it was here that the young Archimedes was inspired by the work of a mechanical genius, called Ctesibius. He would have a simple but brilliant idea that would literally change time forever.

Who was Ctesibius? Stay tune, I’ll introduce him in Part II. To be continuous…

Antikythera Mechanism (Part I)